If you need to file a claim, our carrier partners prefer you report it directly so they can capture every detail right from the source. To make this as easy as possible, we've provided a list of carriers and their claims contact links below. That said — just because you’re filing directly doesn’t mean you’re on your own. We’re here to support you through the process, answer questions, and advocate on your behalf if anything feels off. Don’t hesitate to reach out if you need guidance at any point.
To file a claim with 1859 Mutual:
📞Call: 800-342-2521
💻 Or to file online: Click here to be redirected to the 1859 Mutual claims page.
To file a claim with Aegis:
📞Call: 800-233-2160
💻 Or to Email: Click here to email your claim to Aegis directly.
To file a claim with Auto-Owners ***Please Contact Your Local Agent First***
To file a claim with Berkshire-Hathway GUARD:
📞Call: 888-639-2567
💻 Or to file online: Click here to be redirected to the Bershire-Hathway GUARD claims page.
To file a claim with Celina:
📞Call: 800-334-0090
💻 Or to file online: Click here to be redirected to the Celina claims page.
To file a claim with Dairyland:
📞Call: 800-669-2214
💻 Or to file online: Click here to be redirected to the Dairy Land claims page.
To file a claim with Donegal:
📞Call: 800 877-0600
💻 Or to file online: Click here to be redirected to the Donegal claims page.
To file a claim with Encvoa ***Please Contact Your Local Agent First***
To file a claim with Foremost:
📞Call: 800-527-3905
💻 Or to file online: Click here to be redirected to the Foremost claims page.
To file a claim with Founders:
📞Call: 847-768-0040
💻 Or to file online: Click here to be redirected to the Founders claims page.
To file a claim with Geico:
📞Call: 800-841-3000
💻 Or to file online: Click here to be redirected to the Geico claims page.
To file a claim with Grange:
📞Call: 866-767-0150
💻 Or to file online: Click here to be redirected to the Grange claims page.
To file a claim with Grinell ***Please Contact Your Local Agent First***
To file a claim with Hastings:
📞Call: 800-442-8277
💻 Or to file online: Click here to be redirected to the Hastings Mutual claims page.
To file a claim with Nationwide:
📞Call: 800-421-3535
💻 Or to file online: Click here to be redirected to the Nationwide claims page.
To file a claim with Ohio Mutual:
📞Call: 800-686-3011
💻 Or to file online: Click here to be redirected to the Mennonite Mutual claims page.
To file a claim with Progressive:
📞Call: 800-776-4737
💻 Or to file online: Click here to be redirected to the Progressive claims page.
To file a claim with Trexis:
📞Call: 877-384-7466
💻 Or to file online: Click here to be redirected to the Trexis claims page.
To file a claim with Vacant Express:
📞Call: +1800-788-4780" rel="">800-788-4780
💻 Or to email: Click here to email your claim to Vacant Express directly.
To file a claim with Wayne:
📞Call: 800-222-3873
💻 Or to file online: Click here to be redirected to the Wayne claims page.
To file a claim with Western Reserve ***Please Contact Your Local Agent First***:
To file a claim with Wyandot Mutual:
📞Call: 419-294-2862
💻 Or to file online: Click here to be redirected to the Wyandot Mutual claims page.
Info on this site is general and not insurance advice. Coverage varies and is subject to underwriting. Consult a licensed agent. OIFS is not liable for any losses from use.
Copyright © 2025 OIFS - All Rights Reserved.
We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.